The new 2025–2030 U.S. Dietary Guidelines have ignited controversy, and for once, nutrition policy is trending. From an upside-down food pyramid stacked with red meat, butter, and full-fat dairy to confusing messaging on saturated fat, processed foods, and plant-based diets, many experts are asking: How did we get here?
I joined the hosts of the Nutrition for Noobs podcast to unpack the disconnect between the 20-member Scientific Advisory Committee and the nine-person review panel, the role of ideology and industry ties, and why the final visuals contradict the written recommendations.
We cover:
• Why the inverted food pyramid is misleading (and possibly unworkable)
• The saturated fat contradiction, and what the evidence really says
• Red meat, cancer risk, and what the guidelines leave out
• The problematic treatment of vegan and plant-based diets
• Dairy recommendations, lactose intolerance, and equity concerns
• Ultra-processed foods, breakfast cereals, and nuance lost in translation
• And much more!
You can listen to the audio version on your favourite podcasting app, or watch the video on YouTube below!
Dr. Matthew Nagra is a Naturopathic Doctor in Vancouver who is passionate about evidence-based nutrition and medicine. In addition to his online and public speaking work, he employs a wide range lifestyle interventions, including plant-based nutrition, as well as physical therapies in his practice to help his patients prevent or recover from chronic illnesses and physical injuries. Holding a Plant-Based Nutrition Certification from Cornell University and the T. Colin Campbell Center for Nutrition Studies, he has penned several articles on the topic, underlining his specialized training in nutrition.